Political insider: Conservation group names Melvin to its 'Dirty Dozen'

Sept. 17, 2010 12:00 AM

State Sen. Al Melvin has hit the big time, making the cut to be one of just 12 lawmakers and governors nationwide to be recognized by the League of Conservation Voters. But it's no cause for breaking out the recyclable champagne bottles.

The league has named Melvin, R-Tucson, to its national "Dirty Dozen" list for his environmental-voting record.


"You could probably find more legislators who are worse on the environment, but not one who is so out of touch with his district," said Steve Arnquist, executive director of the Arizona LCV.

Melvin's voting record on issues such as establishing a constitutional right to hunt and fish or blocking the state from setting its own greenhouse-gas emission standards pales in comparison with that of his seatmates, both current and in the recent past, Arnquist said. Legislative District 26, which Melvin represents, has produced lawmakers who have posted pro-environment records, he said.

In the past year, the league gave Melvin a 25 percent rating. It wasn't the lowest: Seven other senators scored lower than Melvin.

- Mary Jo Pitzl


Read more: